Sunbury Sub Shop | Our Story

Hoagies on Market Street
We're a counter-service sub shop in the heart of downtown Sunbury. Some of you have been eating our hoagies for 60 years.

Maria and Lou
Maria Leib and her son Lou Sheller owned the shop for a long time, and Maria is the daughter of the original owner. Plenty of you still ask for them by name.

New owners, same corner
Maria and Lou sold the shop to local owners, Chris and family. We take cards now, which a lot of you asked for.

How the counter works
You order at the counter and we make your sub at the small bar right there. When it's ready, grab it from the counter and take a seat at the bar or one of the tables, or take it to go.

Hot pepper relish
The hot pepper relish goes on any sub. Our oil is a mix of seasonings, vinegar and oil, so ask for both.