Meatball Cosmo
$7.20+
A meatball-filled sub sandwich, available in small or large sizes.
“Great place for delicious Cosmo's especially the Ham and Cheese. Highly recommend for anyone looking for good subs”

Meat-filled and cheese-filled subs at Sunbury Sub Shop in Sunbury come in both small and large sizes, with pickup available.
Order onlineMeatball Cosmo
$7.20+
A meatball-filled sub sandwich, available in small or large sizes.
“Great place for delicious Cosmo's especially the Ham and Cheese. Highly recommend for anyone looking for good subs”
Party Tray
$71.25
Choose five cold subs from a selection of eight varieties.
“Great subs by maria.”
Pizza Roll
$7.10+
A pizza-style sub with Provolone, spaghetti sauce, oregano, and Parmesan.
“Please note that payment is accepted in cash only. The establishment offers fantastic subs and is conveniently located in the heart of downtown Sunbury. The shop provides seating at approximately a dozen counter seats and a few tables. Besides subs, they also offer a selection of Middleswarth chips and a cooler filled with various beverages. The large-sized subs are quite generous, potentially providing two meals for most individuals. I particularly enjoy the toasted cosmos. I highly recommend this place.”
Regular
$6.60+
A hoagie with chopped and spiced ham, Dutch loaf, salami, and Provolone.
“When you just want a really good hoagie, come here, you won't be disappointed”
Capicola & Cheese
$7.20+
A capicola ham and Provolone sub with vegetables and seasonings.
“One of the best subs I’ve had and very large and very good price !”
Cheese Steak
$7.60+
A steak sub with Provolone, fried onions, spaghetti sauce, and Parmesan.
“We love this place. Cheese steaks are the best around. Great staff”
Cheese Sub
$7.00+
A Provolone sub topped with mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
“Been eating their hoagies for 60 years and not about to stop! The friendliest staff, always clean, and the best part of everything is it's ALL delicious! If you twist my arm I'm partial to the ham & cheese Cosmo but the entire menu is fantastic!”
Cheeseburger Sub
$7.40+
A burger sub with Provolone, mayonnaise, vegetables, and house dressing.
“The subs were loaded with meat and two people could easily share a 12in and be full. The service was helpful with sharing other local places to checkout. Sandwiches were definitely worth the price. Just a tip its cash only!”
Chicken Steak
$7.60+
A chicken sub with Provolone, fried onions, spaghetti sauce, and Parmesan.
“Are you looking for a great all American sub, this is definitely the place to go! Not only is the food delicious, fresh, an affordable. Customer service goes above and beyond... stop in if you're passing through the area, or if you live in the area For customer service that's hard to beat!!!”
Garden Steak
$7.80+
A steak sub with Provolone, fried onions, lettuce, and tomato.
“Great subs, fast service, friendly faces”
Ham & Cheese
$7.20+
A ham and Provolone sub with fresh vegetables and house oil and vinegar.
“Perfect little sub shop If you’re in Sunbury looking for a delicious sub , please stop you won’t be disappointed. So flavorful , loaded sub I got a ham and cheese it definitely left me wishing I would have gotten a large 10stars”
Hamburger Sub
$7.20+
A hamburger patty served as a sub, with small and large sizes.
“Best subs in town (sorry Marlin's, you're still #2 in my heart), the staff are always friendly and competent. The food is stellar; I've had everything on the menu and never found an order I couldn't enjoy. In a world where small town charm is quickly fading, this place burns brightly.”
Italian
$7.45+
Sub with capicola, pepperoni, salami, Provolone, mayo, and vegetables.
“Was a delicious Italian sub!! Fair prices too!!”
Meatball
$7.10+
A meatball sub with Provolone and Parmesan cheese.
“Definitely a massive improvement with having new owners. Great place to get a hoagie again. Plus the fact the new owners now takes cards is also a huge bonus”
Pepperoni & Cheese
$7.20+
A sub with pepperoni, Provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
“Best local sub shop, outstanding quality meats and sub rolls. The house made oil is the final touch that makes the best sub in the area even better. They offer dine in and take out. Made to order subs fast, fresh and the best quality.”
Tuna & Cheese
$7.10+
A tuna and Provolone sub topped with mayonnaise and fresh vegetables.
“I had a tuna fish hoagie and it was absolutely delicious 😋 whoever made it it was perfectly made...”
Turkey & Cheese
$7.75+
An oven-roasted turkey and Provolone sub with fresh vegetables.
“Great turkey and cheese hoagie”
Sunbury Sub Shop serves subs with fillings such as oven-roasted turkey, tuna, and capicola ham. Lettuce, tomato, and onion accompany those fillings, along with provolone cheese and mayo.
Regular layers chopped ham, spiced ham, Dutch loaf, and salami. Meatball pairs meatballs with provolone and Parmesan. Pizza Roll combines spaghetti sauce, provolone, oregano, and Parmesan.
Visit us in Sunbury for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Chicken Steak comes with chicken, provolone, fried onions, spaghetti sauce, and Parmesan; add sweet peppers or hot hoagie relish to yours.